It’s that time of the school year: Countless social media posts celebrating all-state ensembles, superior festival ratings, and on and on about “winning” (and often by teachers who have the advantage of affluent environments to foster the success). Amidst this often ego-driven high-fiving (and I’m just as guilty as anyone else!), I was blessed to discover of this video of the great jazz (though classically trained as well!) clarinet player and singer Doreen Ketchens and her band so I would be reminded of how students SHOULD be “winning”…that this excellent playing (and singing!) of culturally important and relevant music on traditional band instruments with such expression and feeling–on a street corner rather than Carnegie Hall or other prestigious venue, not in expensive concert dress or with top-of-the-line equipment, with what might be considered “unbalanced” ensemble instrumentation, and not for any apparent extrinsic reward like money or prestige–is a true goal for students.
I certainly do NOT approve of the cheating by educators, but was it necessary for the defendants to remain in jail while awaiting sentencing, or that they were charged under racketeering laws used for organized crime that did not seem to this case? And could this heavy-handedness be yet another example of the assault against educators, and, in this instance, African-American ones as well?
It is within the corporate realm that so-called education reformers have amassed billions of dollars for their unsuccessful reform efforts and vicious attacks on teachers. Typically, when there is wrongdoing in this corporate realm, entire businesses are charged, fined, etc., while individuals are less likely to be indicted. In fairness, shouldn’t that be the case in this scandal as well? Though there are individuals at fault (as in corporate scandals), it seems like this issue is the result of systemic industry-wide problems caused by the over-emphasis of testing results and maybe it is from this wider perspective we need to solve the issue.
But instead, we single out a few educators, throw the book at them, and feel smug that justice has been served. I don’t believe this is fair or that it will ameliorate further abuses. And, sadly, justice has not been served for under-served, over-tested students.